Elden Ring: Nightreign Tier List

Elden Ring: Nightreign changes the way players engage with team-based combat. When playing with randoms, the ideal class isn't just about raw damage—it's about independence, survivability, and the ability to make clutch plays without relying on voice chat or synchronized strategies. This tier list is based on the latest insights from Mobalytics and firsthand player analysis.

S-Tier – Best for Carrying With No Communication

Ironeye

Ironeye is the quintessential solo carry in random matchmaking. His passive, Eagle Eye, boosts loot quality for the whole team, ensuring stronger builds as the game progresses. His ranged attacks let him kite effectively, and his Marking ability helps him avoid needing a tank in the frontline. His bow and ultimate are perfect for reviving downed teammates without risking himself.

Raider

Tanky and aggressive, the Raider leads the charge with powerful staggers and crowd control. His presence alone makes fights more manageable for allies. Totem Stela, his ultimate, provides a versatile option: either elevate his team’s damage or secure revives and map control. He’s a natural leader in chaotic environments.

Executor

For players with sharp parry timing, Executor is a game-changer. He can hard carry even if teammates are underperforming. His ultimate, Aspect of the Crucible: Beast, is a life-saver, offering a full heal and HP buff when things go south. He thrives in solo or uncoordinated play.

Wylder

Wylder’s kit is forgiving for solo play. He’s versatile with weapons, which lets him adapt when teammates ignore routing. His cheat-death passive gives him a second chance even when isolated. For independent players who like to carve their own path, Wylder is a top-tier choice.

A-Tier – Strong, But Needs Support or Favorable RNG

Duchess

Duchess can snowball hard if she gets the right weapons with status effects. Her dodging mechanics are rewarding but don't lead directly into counter-offense like Executor’s parries. Her ultimate, Finale, turns the team invisible—but if allies still get hit, its effectiveness drops. Best used selfishly in random queues.

Guardian

Guardian is the most reliable support option for random groups. He’s tanky and excels at reviving allies. Wings of Salvation is a solid ultimate, especially for saving runs when allies are downed. However, if his team isn’t putting out enough damage, his lack of offensive power becomes apparent.

Revenant

Revenant shines when she finds the right FP and Faith-based gear, but her damage doesn’t scale easily without it. She has a strong ultimate that supports allies, but it won’t carry a team alone. With high-risk, medium-reward gameplay, she’s better suited for players who enjoy calculated support.

B-Tier – High Skill, Low Consistency in Randoms

Recluse

Recluse has the potential to dominate in coordinated play, but her reliance on specific affinities and Magic Cocktail spells make her frustrating in random lobbies. Teammates can easily disrupt her setups. She’s squishy without the right items, and her window of impact is small. That said, skilled players can still find success with her in the right situations.

Final Thoughts

This tier list is built for those diving into Elden Ring: Nightreign without a pre-made party. In random matchups, look for Nightfarers who can stand on their own or bend the odds in your favor regardless of what your teammates are doing. If you want raw carry power, Ironeye, Raider, Executor, and Wylder are unmatched. If you prefer support or have confidence in RNG, Duchess, Guardian, and Revenant are solid picks. Recluse might frustrate new players, but has a high ceiling when mastered.

Check back on GameSoles for frequent updates as balance patches drop and new Nightfarers enter the arena. We’ll continue tracking meta shifts and gameplay trends to help you stay ahead.

Check out our Elden Ring Nightreign and Elden Ring Nightreign Revenant for more dark fantasy RPG coverage.